Topics in ESG Paul Walsh BA LLM (UWA)
ESG Management Law Division
Environmental, social and governance (ESG) factors have become increasingly important for businesses, investors and stakeholders in Ireland and around the world. ESG refers to the non-financial aspects of a company’s performance, such as its environmental impact, social responsibility, ethical conduct and corporate governance. ESG issues can affect the long-term sustainability, reputation and value of a company, as well as its ability to attract and retain talent, customers and capital.
In recent years, ESG has gained more attention and momentum in Ireland, driven by several factors, such as:
•The global climate crisis and the need to transition to a low-carbon economy
•The COVID-19 pandemic and its social and economic impacts
•The growing demand from investors, regulators and consumers for more transparency and accountability on ESG matters
•The increasing awareness and activism of civil society and NGOs on ESG issues
•The development and implementation of new policies and standards at the European and national level, such as the EU Green Deal, the EU Taxonomy, the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) and the Climate Action Plan 2021
As a result of these drivers, ESG has become a strategic priority for many Irish companies, who are taking various actions to improve their ESG performance and disclosure, such as:
•Setting ambitious targets and commitments on climate action, biodiversity, diversity and inclusion, human rights and other ESG topics
•Measuring and reporting on their ESG impacts, risks and opportunities using frameworks such as the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI), the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) or the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD)
•Seeking independent verification and assurance of their ESG data and claims to enhance their credibility and avoid greenwashing
•Engaging with their supply chain partners to ensure alignment and collaboration on ESG goals and practices
•Integrating ESG criteria into their investment decisions, product development, innovation and stakeholder relations
ESG is not only a challenge but also an opportunity for Irish companies to create value, enhance resilience and gain competitive advantage in a changing world. According to some sources12, ESG can help companies to:
•Reduce costs and improve efficiency by optimizing their use of resources and reducing waste •Increase revenues and market share by developing new products and services that meet the needs and preferences of environmentally and socially conscious customers
•Attract and retain talent by fostering a culture of purpose, engagement and wellbeing among their employees
•Access capital and finance by demonstrating their alignment with the expectations and requirements of investors, lenders and rating agencies
•Manage risks and reputation by anticipating and addressing potential negative impacts or controversies related to their ESG performance
•Innovate and differentiate by adopting best practices, standards and technologies that enhance their ESG performance
ESG is not a static or one-size-fits-all concept. It is a dynamic and evolving field that requires
continuous learning, adaptation and improvement. In 2023, some of the key ESG trends that Irish
companies will need to watch out for include:
•Moving beyond pledges to action: Companies will need to demonstrate tangible progress towards their ESG goals with clear metrics, milestones and evidence
•Bringing supply chains along: Companies will need to extend their ESG efforts beyond their own operations to their suppliers, distributors and customers
•Preparing for new reporting requirements: Companies will need to get ready for the CSRD, which will introduce mandatory sustainability reporting for thousands of companies across Europe from 2024
•Focusing on biodiversity: Companies will need to recognize the importance of biodiversity for their business continuity and sustainability, as well as their contribution to global targets such as protecting 30% of nature by 2030
•Addressing social inequalities: Companies will need to address the social impacts of the pandemic on their stakeholders, such as health, wellbeing, diversity, inclusion, human rights and community engagement
•Leveraging digitalization: Companies will need to use digital tools and solutions to enhance their ESG data collection, analysis, disclosure and communication
•Building trust: Companies will need to ensure the quality, reliability and comparability of their ESG information, as well as engaging with their stakeholders in an honest and transparent way
ESG is not a trend that will fade away. It is a fundamental shift that will shape the future of business in Ireland. Companies that embrace ESG as an opportunity rather than a burden will be better positioned to succeed in a changing world.
ESG IN IRELAND
ESG is a topical and pertinent issue for businesses with increased focus due to new regulation, consumer demands and investor requirements. There is a move from theoretical views to real action at corporate level, which is expected to intensify. The ESG agenda is now being treated less as optional and increasingly more as a critical issue for businesses, as they face increasing ESG requirements to incorporate into their organizations' processes. These businesses must ensure that their ESG reporting and disclosures are accurate and meet investor demands and avoid reputational risks, especially Greenwashing.
This section discusses the importance of ESG for businesses in Ireland, which has become a more pressing issue due to new regulations, consumer demands, and investor requirements. Companies are moving from theoretical discussions to taking real action to incorporate ESG into their processes, and this trend is expected to continue. ESG is no longer seen as an optional consideration, but rather a critical issue that companies must address. To avoid reputational risks like Greenwashing, companies must ensure that their ESG reporting and disclosures are accurate and meet investor demands. As capital and funding become more closely tied to ESG metrics, companies' access to capital markets will depend on the quality of their ESG disclosures. Companies that fail to meet regulatory obligations may face higher costs of capital.
There are several important ESG trends, developments, and initiatives currently impacting Ireland, including the EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), additional new ESG regulations, Greenwashing, and Green finance. The EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) is a new regulation that will have a significant impact on businesses in Ireland. The CSRD will apply to large undertakings with balance sheets of more than €20m, turnover exceeding €40m, and average employees exceeding 250, as well as all companies listed on regulated markets (other than listed micro undertakings). The CSRD aims to provide greater harmonization of ESG reporting and accountability for impact, particularly as regards avoiding Greenwashing. The CSRD will require companies to disclose information on a wide range of sustainability topics, including environmental, social, and governance issues. This information will need to be reported in a standardized format, making it easier for investors and other stakeholders to compare companies' ESG performance. The CSRD is expected to be of particular interest to the investor and asset management community, who have expressed difficulties with gathering consistent information required for their underlying investments in order to comply with their own obligations under the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulations (SFDR).
The CSRD must be transposed into Irish law by 6 July 2024. Companies that fall under the scope of the CSRD will need to ensure that their ESG reporting and disclosures are accurate and meet the new regulatory requirements. Failure to comply with the CSRD could result in reputational risks, as well as higher costs of capital. However, companies that successfully implement ESG strategies and meet the new regulatory requirements may be better positioned to access capital markets and attract investors who are increasingly focused on sustainability issues. The EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) requires companies to disclose information on a wide range of sustainability topics. This business' impact on sustainability matters, and also to understand how sustainability matters affect its development, performance, and position. This is referred to as "double materiality" reporting. The CSRD requires companies to report on environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues, including climate change, biodiversity, water, and air pollution, as well as human rights, social issues, and anti-corruption measures. Companies will also need to report on their business model, strategy, and risks related to sustainability matters. The CSRD aims to provide greater harmonization of ESG reporting and accountability for impact, particularly as regards avoiding Greenwashing. The CSRD will require companies to report this information in a standardized format, making it easier for investors and other stakeholders to compare companies' ESG performance. The implementation schedule for the CSRD means that companies already subject to the Non-Financial Reporting Directive (NFRD) will have to include disclosure requirements in their report for the financial year 2024. Other large companies will have to report in 2025, and thereafter some listed SMEs and other small and non-complex credit institutions and captive insurance undertakings will be required to report in financial year 2026, with the remaining companies under scope including non-EU undertakings with net turnover over €150 million (if they have any subsidiary or branch in the EU) being required to report by financial year 2028. Overall, the CSRD will require companies to provide more detailed and standardized information on their ESG performance, which will be of particular interest to the investor and asset management community. Companies that successfully implement ESG strategies and meet the new regulatory requirements may be better positioned to access capital markets and attract investors who are increasingly focused on sustainability issues.
The EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) is expected to be of particular interest to the investor and asset management community. This is because investors and asset managers are increasingly focused on sustainability issues and want greater information on sustainability claims by companies. Reports and survey findings have consistently shown that investment and other managers want greater information on sustainability claims by companies, and generally express a view that there is a lack of consistency and/or accuracy in available data. The CSRD aims to provide greater harmonization of ESG reporting and accountability for impact, particularly as regards avoiding Greenwashing. The disclosures created under CSRD should better enable investors to take account of sustainable related risks and opportunities and relieve the data concerns about inadequacies to date. The new reporting requirements will make it easier for investors and asset managers to compare companies' ESG performance and make informed investment decisions. Investors and asset managers are also subject to their own obligations under the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulations (SFDR). The SFDR requires investors and asset managers to disclose information on how they integrate sustainability risks into their investment decision-making process and how they consider the adverse impacts of their investments on sustainability factors. The SFDR also requires investors and asset managers to disclose information on the sustainability characteristics of their products. Overall, the CSRD and SFDR are part of a broader trend towards greater transparency and accountability in ESG reporting. Companies that successfully implement ESG strategies and meet the new regulatory requirements may be better positioned to attract investors who are increasingly focused on sustainability issues. The EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) must be transposed into Irish law by 6 July 2024. This means that Irish businesses within the scope of the CSRD must focus on its requirements and ensure that their ESG reporting and disclosures are accurate and meet the new regulatory requirements. The CSRD as already stated above will apply to large undertakings with balance sheets of more than €20m, turnover exceeding €40m, and average employees exceeding 250, as well as all companies listed on regulated markets (other than listed micro undertakings). The CSRD requires companies to report on a wide range of sustainability topics, including environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues, as well as their business model, strategy, and risks related to sustainability matters. Companies that fall under the scope of the CSRD will need to ensure that their ESG reporting and disclosures are accurate and meet the new regulatory requirements. Failure to comply with the CSRD could result in reputational risks, as well as higher costs of capital. However, companies that successfully implement ESG strategies and meet the new regulatory requirements may be better positioned to access capital markets and attract investors who are increasingly focused on sustainability issues.
Overall, the CSRD is an important regulation that will have a significant impact on businesses in Ireland. Companies that fall under the scope of the CSRD will need to ensure that they comply with the new regulatory requirements and provide more detailed and standardized information on their ESG performance.
The EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) is of particular interest to the investor and asset management community. Investors and asset managers are increasingly focused on sustainability issues and want greater information on sustainability claims by companies. Reports and survey findings have consistently shown that investment and other managers want greater information on sustainability claims by companies, and generally express a view that there is a lack of consistency and/or accuracy in available data. The CSRD aims to provide greater harmonization of ESG reporting and accountability for impact, particularly as regards avoiding Greenwashing. The disclosures created under CSRD should better enable investors to take account of sustainable related risks and opportunities and relieve the data concerns about inadequacies to date. The new reporting requirements will make it easier for investors and asset managers to compare companies' ESG performance and make informed investment decisions. Investors and asset managers are also subject to their own obligations under the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulations (SFDR). The SFDR requires investors and asset managers to disclose information on how they integrate sustainability risks into their investment decision-making process and how they consider the adverse impacts of their investments on sustainability factors. The SFDR also requires investors and asset managers to disclose information on the sustainability characteristics of their products. Overall, the CSRD and SFDR are part of a broader trend towards greater transparency and accountability in ESG reporting. Companies that successfully implement ESG strategies and meet the new regulatory requirements may be better positioned to attract investors who are increasingly focused on sustainability issues.
Firstly, the CSRD will require companies to report a wide range of sustainability information, including environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues, as well as their business model, strategy, and risks related to sustainability matters. This will make it easier for investors and other stakeholders to compare companies' ESG performance and make informed investment decisions. Secondly, the CSRD will require companies to report this information in a standardized format, making it easier for investors and other stakeholders to compare companies' ESG performance. The new reporting requirements will make it easier for investors and asset managers to compare companies' ESG performance and make informed investment decisions. Thirdly, the CSRD will require external audit assurance and reporting standards, which will increase the reliability and accuracy of the reported information. This will help to address concerns about the lack of consistency and/or accuracy in available data. Overall, the CSRD is an important regulation that will have a significant impact on businesses in Ireland. Companies that fall under the scope of the CSRD will need to ensure that they comply with the new regulatory requirements and provide more detailed and standardized information on their ESG performance. The disclosures created under CSRD should better enable investors to take account of sustainable related risks and opportunities and relieve the data concerns about inadequacies to date.
The EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) is applicable in all EU states, and failure to comply with the new regulatory requirements could result in reputational risks, as well as higher costs of capital. Companies that fall under the scope of the CSRD will need to ensure that their ESG reporting and disclosures are accurate and meet the new regulatory requirements. Failure to comply with the CSRD could result in reputational risks, as investors and other stakeholders are increasingly focused on sustainability issues and want greater information on sustainability claims by companies. Companies that fail to comply with the CSRD may be viewed as less transparent and less committed to sustainability, which could negatively impact their reputation and their ability to attract investors. In addition, failure to comply with the CSRD could result in higher costs of capital. As capital and funding become more aligned to demonstrative metrics to indicate an acceptable ESG strategy and compliance level, access to capital markets will be predicated on the quality of the corporate's disclosure. There will likely be an increased cost of capital for those who do not satisfy regulatory obligations. Overall, companies that fall under the scope of the CSRD will need to ensure that they comply with the new regulatory requirements and provide more detailed and standardized information on their ESG performance. Companies that successfully implement ESG strategies and meet the new regulatory requirements may be better positioned to access capital markets and attract investors who are increasingly focused on sustainability issues.
Companies can successfully implement ESG strategies and meet the new legal requirements by taking the following steps:
1. Develop a clear ESG strategy: Companies should develop a clear ESG strategy that aligns with their business model, values, and long-term goals. This strategy should be integrated into the company's overall business strategy and should be supported by senior management.
2. Identify material ESG issues: Companies should identify the ESG issues that are most material to their business and stakeholders. This will help them to prioritize their ESG efforts and ensure that they are focusing on the issues that matter most.
3. Establish ESG metrics and targets: Companies should establish ESG metrics and targets that are aligned with their ESG strategy and material issues. These metrics and targets should be measurable, time-bound, and relevant to the company's business.
4. Implement ESG policies and procedures: Companies should implement ESG policies and procedures that support their ESG strategy and help them to achieve their ESG targets. These policies and procedures should be integrated into the company's overall management systems and should be regularly reviewed and updated.
5. Monitor and report on ESG performance: Companies should monitor and report on their ESG performance using standardized reporting frameworks. The new reporting requirements under the CSRD will require companies to report on a wide range of sustainability topics, including environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues, as well as their business model, strategy, and risks related to sustainability matters. Companies should ensure that their ESG reporting and disclosures are accurate and meet the new regulatory requirements.
6. Engage with stakeholders: Companies should engage with their stakeholders, including investors, customers, employees, and communities, on ESG issues. This will help them to understand stakeholder expectations and concerns and to build trust and credibility with their stakeholders. Overall, companies that successfully implement ESG strategies and meet the new regulatory requirements may be better positioned to access capital markets and attract investors who are increasingly focused on sustainability issues.
The EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) will make it easier for investors and asset managers to compare companies' ESG performance in several ways:
1. Standardized reporting format: The CSRD will require companies to report their sustainability information in a standardized format, making it easier for investors and asset managers to compare companies' ESG performance. The new format for CSRD reporting will be in a single economic reporting format.
2. More detailed information: The CSRD will require companies to report a wide range of sustainability information, including environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues, as well as their business model, strategy, and risks related to sustainability matters. This will provide investors and asset managers with more detailed information on companies' ESG performance.
3. External audit assurance and reporting standards: The CSRD will require external audit assurance and reporting standards, which will increase the reliability and accuracy of the reported information. This will help to address concerns about the lack of consistency and/or accuracy in available data.
4. Comparable information: The CSRD will require companies to report on a wide range of sustainability topics using standardized reporting frameworks. This will make it easier for investors and asset managers to compare companies' ESG performance and make informed investment decisions. Overall, the CSRD is an important regulation that will have a significant impact on businesses in Ireland.
Companies that fall under the scope of the CSRD will need to ensure that they comply with the new regulatory requirements and provide more detailed and standardized information on their ESG performance. The disclosures created under CSRD should better enable investors to take account of sustainable related risks and opportunities and relieve the data concerns about inadequacies to date.
There are several broader trends towards greater transparency and accountability in ESG reporting, including:
1. Increased regulatory requirements: There has been a trend towards increased regulatory requirements for ESG reporting, with new regulations such as the EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) and the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) requiring companies to report more detailed and standardized information on their ESG performance.
2. Investor pressure: Investors are increasingly focused on sustainability issues and are demanding more information on companies' ESG performance. This has led to a trend towards greater transparency and accountability in ESG reporting, as companies seek to meet investor expectations and attract investment.
3. Market development: The development of sustainable finance markets has also contributed to the trend towards greater transparency and accountability in ESG reporting. As sustainable finance markets grow, there is a greater need for standardized and reliable information on companies' ESG performance.
4. Voluntary reporting frameworks: There has been a trend towards the adoption of voluntary reporting frameworks, such as the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) and the Task Force on Climate related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), which provide guidance on ESG reporting and help companies to improve the quality and consistency of their disclosures.
The trend towards greater transparency and accountability in ESG reporting is driven by a combination of regulatory requirements, investor pressure, market development, and voluntary reporting frameworks. Companies that successfully implement ESG strategies and meet the new regulatory requirements may be better positioned to access capital markets and attract investors who are increasingly focused on sustainability issues.
Companies can prepare for the implementation of the EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) and ensure that their ESG reporting and disclosures are accurate and meet the new regulatory requirements by taking the following steps:
1. Understand the scope of the CSRD: Companies should understand whether they fall under the scope of the CSRD and what the new regulatory requirements will mean for their ESG reporting and disclosures.
2. Identify material ESG issues: Companies should identify the ESG issues that are most material to their business and stakeholders. This will help them to prioritize their ESG efforts and ensure that they are focusing on the issues that matter most.
3. Develop a clear ESG strategy: Companies should develop a clear ESG strategy that aligns with their business model, values, and long-term goals. This strategy should be integrated into the company's overall business strategy and should be supported by senior management.
4. Establish ESG metrics and targets: Companies should establish ESG metrics and targets that are aligned with their ESG strategy and material issues. These metrics and targets should be measurable, time-bound, and relevant to the company's business.
5. Implement ESG policies and procedures: Companies should implement ESG policies and procedures that support their ESG strategy and help them to achieve their ESG targets. These policies and procedures should be integrated into the company's overall management systems and should be regularly reviewed and updated.
6. Monitor and report on ESG performance: Companies should monitor and report on their ESG performance using standardized reporting frameworks. The new reporting requirements under the CSRD will require companies to report on a wide range of sustainability topics, including environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues, as well as their business model, strategy, and risks related to sustainability matters. Companies should ensure that their ESG reporting and disclosures are accurate and meet the new regulatory requirements.
7. Engage with stakeholders: Companies should engage with their stakeholders, including investors, customers, employees, and communities, on ESG issues. This will help them to understand stakeholder expectations and concerns and to build trust and credibility with their stakeholders.
Companies that successfully implement ESG strategies and meet the new regulatory requirements may be better positioned to access capital markets and attract investors who are increasingly focused on sustainability issues.
Some of the key ESG trends and developments impacting Ireland currently include:
1. The EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD): The CSRD is imminent, and Irish businesses within its scope must focus on its requirements. The new regulation will require companies to report more detailed and standardized information on their ESG performance.
2. Additional new ESG regulation: In addition to the CSRD, there are other new ESG regulations that are impacting businesses in Ireland, such as the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR).
3. Greenwashing: Greenwashing is a trending issue, and the SFDR regime will apply new disclosure requirements to many financial companies with the specific aim of preventing greenwashing and ensuring a consistency of data standardization and transparency on sustainability in financial markets.
4. Green finance: There is a growing trend towards green finance, with investors increasingly focused on sustainability issues and demanding more information on companies' ESG performance. 5. Greater focus on the "Social" component of ESG: There is a growing recognition of the importance of the "Social" component of ESG, with companies being held accountable for their impact on employees, customers, and communities.
These trends and developments are driving a greater focus on ESG issues in Ireland and are creating new opportunities and challenges for businesses in the country.
There are several benefits of implementing ESG strategies and meeting the new regulatory requirements, including: 1. Improved risk management: ESG strategies can help companies to identify and manage risks related to environmental, social, and governance issues. By addressing these risks, companies can reduce their exposure to potential liabilities and reputational damage.
2. Enhanced reputation: Companies that implement ESG strategies and meet the new regulatory requirements may enhance their reputation with stakeholders, including investors, customers, employees, and communities. This can help to attract investment, improve customer loyalty, and attract and retain talent.
3. Access to capital: Companies that successfully implement ESG strategies and meet the new regulatory requirements may be better positioned to access capital markets and attract investors who are increasingly focused on sustainability issues.
4. Improved operational efficiency: ESG strategies can help companies to identify opportunities to improve operational efficiency, reduce costs, and increase profitability. For example, by reducing energy consumption or waste, companies can reduce their environmental impact and save money.
5. Compliance with regulatory requirements: Companies that comply with the new regulatory requirements, such as the EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), can avoid potential penalties and reputational damage associated with non-compliance. Overall, implementing ESG strategies and meeting the new regulatory requirements can help companies to manage risks, enhance their reputation, access capital, improve operational efficiency, and comply with regulatory requirements. By doing so, companies may be better positioned to succeed in a rapidly changing business environment that is increasingly focused on sustainability issues.
To successfully implement ESG strategies and meet the new regulatory requirements, companies can consider the following steps:
1. Understand the regulatory landscape: Companies should familiarize themselves with the specific ESG regulations applicable to their jurisdiction, such as the EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) mentioned in Text 1. This includes understanding the scope, requirements, and timelines for compliance.
2. Conduct a materiality assessment: Identify the ESG issues that are most relevant and impactful to your business and stakeholders. This assessment will help prioritize efforts and focus on areas that matter the most.
3. Develop a robust ESG framework: Establish a comprehensive ESG framework that aligns with industry best practices and regulatory requirements. This framework should include clear goals, targets, and metrics for measuring and reporting ESG performance.
4. Enhance data collection and reporting: Implement systems and processes to collect accurate and reliable ESG data. This may involve integrating ESG considerations into existing reporting mechanisms or adopting specialized ESG reporting tools. Ensure that the data collected aligns with the reporting requirements outlined in the regulations.
5. Engage stakeholders: Engage with internal and external stakeholders to gain their perspectives, address concerns, and incorporate their feedback into the ESG strategy. This can include investors, employees, customers, suppliers, and local communities.
6. Establish governance and accountability: Assign responsibility for ESG implementation and oversight to a dedicated team or individual within the organization. This ensures accountability and facilitates effective monitoring and reporting of ESG initiatives.
7. Seek external expertise: Consider engaging external ESG experts or consultants who can provide guidance on best practices, help navigate regulatory requirements, and assist in developing and implementing effective ESG strategies.
8. Continuously improve and adapt: ESG strategies should be dynamic and responsive to evolving regulations, stakeholder expectations, and emerging sustainability trends. Regularly review and update the ESG framework to ensure it remains relevant and effective. By following these steps, companies can enhance their ESG strategies, meet regulatory requirements, and demonstrate their commitment to sustainable and responsible business practices. What are some voluntary reporting frameworks that companies can use to improve the quality and consistency of their ESG disclosures?
Trends indicate that corporates are electing to make voluntary disclosures against frameworks not required of them. While the specific voluntary reporting frameworks may not be mentioned in the given texts, there are some commonly used frameworks that companies can consider improving the quality and consistency of their ESG disclosures:
1. Global Reporting Initiative (GRI): GRI provides a widely recognized framework for sustainability reporting. It offers guidelines and indicators for companies to report on their economic, environmental, and social performance.
2. Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB): SASB provides industry-specific standards for disclosing financially material sustainability information. It focuses on the disclosure of industry-specific ESG risks and opportunities.
3. Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD): TCFD provides recommendations for companies to disclose climate-related risks and opportunities in their financial filings. It helps companies assess and disclose climate-related risks and opportunities in a consistent and comparable manner.
4. Carbon Disclosure Project (CDP): CDP is an international platform that enables companies to disclose their environmental impacts, including carbon emissions, water usage, and deforestation risks. It provides a standardized framework for reporting and benchmarking environmental performance.
5. United Nations Global Compact (UNGC): UNGC is a voluntary initiative that encourages companies to adopt sustainable and socially responsible policies and practices. It provides a framework for companies to report on their progress in implementing the Ten Principles of the UNGC.
6. Sustainability Reporting Standards by the International Integrated Reporting Council (IIRC): IIRC provides a framework for integrated reporting, which aims to provide a holistic view of a company's value creation over time. It encourages companies to report on their financial, environmental, social, and governance performance in an integrated manner. These frameworks are widely recognized and can help companies improve the quality, consistency, and comparability of their ESG disclosures. It is important for companies to assess which frameworks align best with their industry, stakeholders, and reporting objectives.
How can companies engage with their stakeholders on ESG issues? Companies can engage with their stakeholders on ESG issues through various channels and approaches. Here are some strategies for effective stakeholder engagement on ESG:
1. Identify key stakeholders: Identify the stakeholders who are most relevant to your business and have a significant interest in your ESG performance. This can include investors, employees, customers, suppliers, local communities, NGOs, regulators, and industry associations.
2. Understand stakeholder expectations: Conduct surveys, interviews, or focus groups to understand the ESG priorities, concerns, and expectations of your stakeholders. This will help tailor your engagement efforts to address their specific interests.
3. Establish a dialogue: Foster open and transparent communication channels to engage with stakeholders. This can include regular meetings, forums, webinars, or dedicated ESG communication platforms. Encourage stakeholders to provide feedback, ask questions, and share their perspectives.
4. Share ESG information: Provide clear and accessible information about your ESG initiatives, goals, and progress. This can be done through sustainability reports, dedicated ESG sections on your website, or targeted communications. Use plain language and visual aids to enhance understanding.
5. Collaborate on ESG initiatives: Engage stakeholders in collaborative initiatives to address ESG challenges. This can involve partnerships with NGOs, industry associations, or local communities to develop and implement sustainability projects or initiatives.
6. Seek input in decision-making: Involve stakeholders in the decision-making process related to ESG issues. This can be done through advisory panels, stakeholder consultations, or by seeking their input on specific ESG strategies or policies.
7. Provide training and education: Offer training programs or workshops to educate stakeholders about ESG topics, industry trends, and best practices. This can help build awareness and capacity among stakeholders to actively engage in ESG discussions.
8. Report progress and respond to feedback: Regularly communicate your ESG progress and respond to stakeholder feedback. This demonstrates accountability and shows that their input is valued. Address concerns and provide updates on actions taken to address feedback.
9. Engage through social media and online platforms: Utilize social media platforms and online forums to engage with stakeholders, share ESG updates, and encourage discussions. Monitor and respond to comments and inquiries promptly.
10. Continuous improvement: Continuously evaluate and improve your stakeholder engagement strategies based on feedback and changing stakeholder expectations. Regularly assess the effectiveness of your engagement efforts and make adjustments as needed. By actively engaging with stakeholders on ESG issues, companies can build trust, gain valuable insights, and foster collaborative relationships.
What are some examples of other countries that are leading the way in sustainable finance and ESG reporting? Several countries that are leading the way in sustainable finance and ESG reporting. Here are some examples:
1. Switzerland: Switzerland has been at the forefront of sustainable finance and ESG reporting. It has implemented various initiatives to promote sustainable investments, including the Swiss Sustainable Finance (SSF) organization, which promotes sustainable finance practices and provides guidance to companies and investors.
2. Luxembourg: Luxembourg is recognized as a world-leading pioneer in ESG and sustainable finance. It has established a strong legal and regulatory framework to support sustainable finance, including the Luxembourg Sustainable Finance Initiative (LSFI) and the Luxembourg Green Exchange (LGX), which focuses on green and sustainable securities.
3. New Zealand: New Zealand has taken significant steps in mandatory climate-related disclosures. It has introduced regulations that require certain companies to disclose climate-related risks and opportunities in their financial filings. This demonstrates New Zealand's commitment to advancing sustainable finance and ESG reporting.
4. Singapore: Singapore has emerged as a hub for sustainable finance in Asia. It has implemented various initiatives to promote sustainable investments, including the Monetary Authority of Singapore's Green Finance Action Plan. Singapore is also actively involved in promoting ESG reporting and disclosure practices.
5. Jersey: Jersey, a jurisdiction in the Channel Islands, has been proactive in structuring sustainable funds for international investors. It has developed a framework for structuring funds that meet international ESG standards and attract sustainable investments.
These countries have demonstrated leadership in sustainable finance and ESG reporting through their regulatory frameworks, initiatives, and commitment to promoting sustainable investments. However, it's important to note that sustainable finance and ESG reporting practices are evolving globally, and other countries are also making significant progress in this area.
In July 2021, Ireland took a significant step towards addressing climate change by enacting the Climate Action and Low Carbon Development (Amendment) Act. This legislation commits the country to specific greenhouse gas emission reduction targets for 2030 and 2050, while also providing a comprehensive framework to achieve these objectives.
To enhance sustainability reporting across the European Union, the European Commission proposed the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD). This directive aims to improve the quality, comparability, and relevance of sustainability reports issued by companies within the EU. One of its primary goals is to combat greenwashing, where companies make deceptive claims about their environmental, social, and governance (ESG) performance to gain favour or a competitive advantage.
By curbing greenwashing, the CSRD seeks to bolster the credibility and effectiveness of ESG reporting. This, in turn, enables investors, consumers, and other stakeholders to make informed decisions and assess a company's genuine sustainability performance accurately.
The CSRD will be applicable to all large companies and those listed on regulated markets, excluding listed micro-enterprises. These organizations will be required not only to disclose the impact of sustainability issues on their operations, but also how their activities affect society and the environment.
In line with the broader focus on sustainability, the European Commission's Action Plan for Financing Sustainable Growth identifies "strengthening sustainability disclosures and accounting for rule-making" as a critical area of emphasis among its ten key priorities.
In response to growing stakeholder demands, an increasing number of companies are voluntarily disclosing ESG-related information. However, the CSRD will make such reporting mandatory for companies within its scope. Starting in 2024, these companies will be obligated to report according to common EU reporting standards adopted by the European Commission as delegated acts. The reporting will be based on the financial year 2023 information.
This comprehensive approach towards sustainability reporting and the concerted effort to combat greenwashing is expected to foster greater transparency and accountability among businesses, leading to a more sustainable and responsible corporate landscape within the EU.
Over the next several years, companies will need to carefully consider the timeline and requirements for implementing sustainability reporting standards in accordance with the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) within the European Union.
The timeline for implementation is as follows:
By mid-2023 (FY 2023), the first set of Sustainability Reporting Standards will be made available, based on the draft standards published by the European Financial Reporting Advisory Group in November 2022.
In FY 2024, the second set of Sustainability Reporting Standards will be available, and EU Member States will adopt the EU directive.
By FY 2025, companies will be required to submit their first sustainability reports for the financial year 2024.
The CSRD applies to all large companies operating within the EU that meet any of the following criteria:
Having more than 250 employees
Having an annual turnover of over €40 million
Possessing total assets worth more than €20 million for listed companies.
Small and medium-sized listed companies are granted an additional three years to comply with the reporting requirements.
Companies must include a dedicated section in their management report, providing information necessary to understand their impacts and how sustainability matters affect their development, performance, and position. Notably, sustainability reporting under the CSRD will require external verification, unlike the previous Non-financial Reporting Directive. Companies will be required to seek limited assurance of their sustainability information, which entails a level of external scrutiny, though less extensive than a financial audit statement.
Mandatory disclosures should encompass information relating to intangibles, such as social, human, and intellectual capital. Additionally, reporting should align with the requirements of the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) and the EU Taxonomy Regulation.
Entities will be exempt from the reporting requirements if the consolidated management report of their parent company already includes the results of the company and its subsidiaries.
Overall, mandating standardized reporting enhances comparability in the public domain, enabling organizations to be held accountable by their stakeholders. This increased transparency is likely to influence procurement processes, as stakeholders and consumers place a greater emphasis on a company's sustainability performance and environmental, social, and governance practices.